← All episodes
05

The New Pearl Harbor

Dale Has Opinions About Structural Engineering. Dale Once Microwaved a Fork.

A heavy week. Bryce opens by reminding everyone that nearly three thousand real people died and that this matters more than anything Dale is about to say. Dale agrees, observes eleven respectful seconds of silence, and then unrolls a poster tube. The poster is laminated. Of course it's laminated.

Segment 01 / 02

Dale vs. Steel

What were we conditioned to believe?

That 19 Al-Qaeda hijackers directed by Osama bin Laden attacked America on September 11, 2001 — the conclusion of the largest criminal investigation in human history, which Dale has not read, because it is not laminated.

What is the actual truth?

Dale has never taken a physics class, but he has strong opinions about steel. His credentials: he once microwaved a fork, and he considers this field experience. When Bryce explained that steel doesn’t need to melt to fail — it just needs to soften, like Dale at a timeshare presentation — Dale called the metallurgy "convenient."

Dale’s evidence tour eventually arrived where it always arrives, and the eyebrow thing happened. HR — Bryce’s mom — has now created a dedicated folder. Bryce would like the record to show that "some guys had a camcorder in New Jersey" would, as an evidentiary standard, also implicate every dad at every little league game in 2001.

Dale’s theory requires thousands of demolition charges installed in secret, in occupied office towers, by a workforce that has stayed silent for a quarter century. Dale’s own workforce — Dale — could not stay silent about Bryce’s surprise party. He lasted four hours. It was Dale’s party.

On WTC7, Dale is at his most confident, which long-time listeners know is the warning sign. "No plane hit it, Bryce." Correct, Dale — a 110-story building hit it. Dale’s model of fire is a candle. Dale’s model of everything is a candle.

Why?

Because "incompetence, missed warnings, and a hundred small failures" doesn’t give Dale anyone to be mad at, and Dale needs a villain with a face. Real tragedy is unbearable precisely because it’s senseless — so Dale installs sense into it, the way he installed his own ceiling fan: confidently, and now nothing in the house works.

Segment 02 / 02

A Stopped Dale Is Right Twice a Day

What were we conditioned to believe?

That the Patriot Act was a necessary emergency measure to protect Americans from terrorism.

What is the actual truth?

And here, listeners, something terrible happened: Dale was almost right. The Patriot Act did pass in 45 days with minimal review. It did authorize sweeping surveillance of ordinary Americans. Civil-liberties lawyers, judges, and several of the bill’s own authors have spent twenty years saying so, in public, in books Dale could read.

Bryce sat stunned as Dale — citing an actual, checkable fact — noted that much of the bill existed in draft form before the attack. "Drafts exist, Dale," Bryce said carefully, "your wedding speech was written before the wedding and you still blew that up." But the point stood. The point stood and Bryce hated it.

Dale then celebrated his one verified fact by connecting it, via yarn, to the firmament. He had it, listeners. He had a real civil-liberties critique, shared by the ACLU and several Supreme Court justices, and he traded it for a dome. Bryce has started a counter on the wall: DAYS SINCE DALE RUINED A VALID POINT: 0.

Why?

Because a frightened population really will surrender rights a calm one never would — which is, verbatim, the thesis of a thousand mainstream law-review articles. Dale arrived at it by yarn. The destination was real; the vehicle was a duck.

Field Recordings / moments from the episode

Jet fuel can’t melt steel beams, Bryce.
— Dale
You can’t melt a Hot Pocket evenly, Dale, and you don’t accuse the microwave of treason. Actually — you did. I forgot about the fork tribunal.
— Bryce
I’m telling you, the bill was already written.
— Dale
That part’s actually documented, Dale, which is why it’s so upsetting that your next slide is about the dome.
— Bryce
I observe the silence every year, Bryce. I’m respectful. THEN I get the poster tube.
— Dale

Brought to you by FreedomGrade™ Window Blinds — because someone is watching (it’s your phone, Dale, it’s always been your phone)